Conestoga Restaurant

Mike Noll

a month ago

Don’t remember how I found this place but it’s a hidden gem in Lancaster city on the Conestoga River. Third time there today and just had to try the pizza. On NYeve we went for dinner I had chicken parm amazing and my wife had Penne with Vodka sauce, she said it was the best vodka sauce she ever had. While eating the couple beside ordered a pizza it looked amazing hence why we went there today for lunch. 5 ⭐️’s for sure!

Sandra Kuhns

2 months ago

The waitress Les was so good. The catfish was slamming and you get 2 filets! The Marshmallow Mule was so good, and don't get me started on the Blueberry Creme Brulee Cheesecake! The owner spoke to us and he was so nice. My new to go place to eat!

Bridgette Winters

a month ago

My husband and I have come here twice within a week. The staff and the owner made us feel special, the ambiance is so welcoming and relaxing. The food was delicious! Shoutout to the chefs/cooks Danny, Danielle & Leah! I highly recommend this restaurant.

Autumn Pyszka

9 months ago

Our view and service was great!! Loved the atmosphere, sitting outside by the water. Didn't love hearing the traffic near by. Our server was incredible. The crab sandwich was delicious! The chef even made a substitute exception for us. I definitely recommend checking out Conestoga restaurant.

Lisa Puluski

3 months ago

Had lunch here today with 2 other friends. Service was great. A bunch of people came all at once and she stayed on top of things. My girlfriend had the Mac and cheese bake, we all tried some! Huge portion and delicious. This may be our new monthly spot. They can make any drink a great mock tail as well! I highly suggest trying the place out!

Jungle queen Sheena

Edited 11 months ago

The food so good!! I love that it’s all made in house. Even the breads and pizza doughs, even the salad dressings!! When you wanna eat natural this is the place to go !!! Everything I ate was soooo good! The menu has some things I’ve never heard of. I’m so glad to see a unique menu. Not just the same old , same old. The southwest egg rolls were great! And the crusty French bread served with my crab dip was literally perfect!!! I come back time and time again because I can’t get over how good the food is here! Just went again yesterday and had the prime rib. Oh my Lord!!! The food is great. The atmosphere is amazing and the staff is incredible!!!

Kevin Mull

6 months ago

What a wonderful experience. Paige our server was very attentive and personable. I had the Italian wrap and it was packed with meat and cheese and was not on visually appealing but a winner for the taste buds. Kudos to new owner Brian and his new endeavor!

Chetan Patel

a month ago

Our company had the pleasure of dining here for a holiday dinner, and it was an absolutely wonderful experience from start to finish. The service was exceptional, thoughtful, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. The prep and details were handled with care, and it truly felt like the staff went out of their way to make sure our group was comfortable and taken care of. The food was amazing and well presented.

Brandon Harriford

5 months ago

So we visited Dutch Wonderland in Lancaster, PA earlier in the day on Sunday. The food inside the theme park was terrible, so we needed some great food to make up for that part of Dutch Wonderland 🤣

April Zook

3 months ago

I can’t understand why this place isn’t packed! The outdoor scene is lovely by the water, the food and service are great, ample parking, nice, indoor dining, and pub with plenty of room, good music, and drinks! I’d like to highlight their incredible soft pretzel that totally blew me away, because I don’t even like soft pretzels, and this thing was amazing, made fresh in-house. Next highlight is their pizza, just wow. The prices are good too, why isn’t there a line to be seated?! Another hidden gem!